Guilting - Revision history

Staffan Björk at 11:31, 1 November 2014

2014-11-01T11:31:55Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 11:31, 1 November 2014
Line 25:		Line 25:
	Since feeling guilt is rarely a pleasurable experience, being on the receiving end of [[Guilting]], or even seeing that this may occur, can lead to [[Tension]]. Since [[Guilting]] also divides players in those that are blamed and those not blamed, the pattern is likely to work against a sense of [[Togetherness]] among all players.		Since feeling guilt is rarely a pleasurable experience, being on the receiving end of [[Guilting]], or even seeing that this may occur, can lead to [[Tension]]. Since [[Guilting]] also divides players in those that are blamed and those not blamed, the pattern is likely to work against a sense of [[Togetherness]] among all players.

	The possibility of [[Guilting]] opens up for [[Social Roles]] both on the sending and receiving end of the [[Guilting]].		The possibility of [[Guilting]] opens up for [[Social Roles]] both on the sending and receiving end of the [[Guilting]]. Being good at [[Guilting]] (or avoiding to do it or be affected by it) can be a [[Social Skills\|Social Skill]].

	== Relations ==		== Relations ==
	=== Can Instantiate ===		=== Can Instantiate ===
	[[Social Roles]],		[[Social Roles]],
			[[Social Skills]],
	[[Tension]]		[[Tension]]

Staffan Björk at 13:09, 2 September 2014

2014-09-02T13:09:52Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 13:09, 2 September 2014
Line 23:		Line 23:

	== Consequences ==		== Consequences ==
	Since feeling guilt is rarely a pleasurable experience, being on the receiving end of [[Guilting]], or even seeing that this may occur, can lead to [[Tension]].		Since feeling guilt is rarely a pleasurable experience, being on the receiving end of [[Guilting]], or even seeing that this may occur, can lead to [[Tension]]. Since [[Guilting]] also divides players in those that are blamed and those not blamed, the pattern is likely to work against a sense of [[Togetherness]] among all players.

	The possibility of [[Guilting]] opens up for [[Social Roles]] both on the sending and receiving end of the [[Guilting]].		The possibility of [[Guilting]] opens up for [[Social Roles]] both on the sending and receiving end of the [[Guilting]].
Line 61:		Line 61:

	=== Potentially Conflicting With ===		=== Potentially Conflicting With ===
	-		[[Togetherness]]

	== History ==		== History ==

Staffan Björk at 12:46, 2 September 2014

2014-09-02T12:46:41Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 12:46, 2 September 2014
Line 16:		Line 16:

	== Using the pattern ==		== Using the pattern ==
	[[Guilting]] consists of two parts. The first part is that players have other players they feel a connection with. This can be formalized [[Social Organizations]] such as [[Teams]] or [[Guilds]], but any group that they feel [[Loyalty]] to can suffice as can other players with which they have [[Symbiotic Player Relations]]. The second part of [[Guilting]] is to make players feel that they should perform some form of action to other players. This is quite often set up by [[Delayed Reciprocity]], for example through [[Altruistic Actions]] such as [[Free Gift Inventories]], but any type of [[Social Dilemmas]] can work as well. [[Asynchronous Collaborative Actions]] shows how [[Social Dilemmas]] can be used for this purpose without the players needing to interact directly with each other, or even know much about each other. Another option to create [[Guilting]] is to put one or more players in a state of [[Helplessness]] and then let them ask for help through [[Communication Channels]] or [[Unmediated Social Interaction]].		While [[Guilting]] is often seen as a negative aspect of gameplay, understanding what may may it occur can both help in ensure that it is not part of a game design or identifying when it can be motivated to be present. That said, [[Guilting]] consists of two parts. The first part is that players have other players they feel a connection with. This can be formalized [[Social Organizations]] such as [[Teams]] or [[Guilds]], but any group that they feel [[Loyalty]] to can suffice as can other players with which they have [[Symbiotic Player Relations]]. The second part of [[Guilting]] is to make players feel that they should perform some form of action to other players. This is quite often set up by [[Delayed Reciprocity]], for example through [[Altruistic Actions]] such as [[Free Gift Inventories]], but any type of [[Social Dilemmas]] can work as well. [[Asynchronous Collaborative Actions]] shows how [[Social Dilemmas]] can be used for this purpose without the players needing to interact directly with each other, or even know much about each other. Another option to create [[Guilting]] is to put one or more players in a state of [[Helplessness]] and then let them ask for help through [[Communication Channels]] or [[Unmediated Social Interaction]]. While [[Mutual FUBAR Enjoyment]] may be pleasurable to those taking part of it, the collapse of gameplay due to some failure is likely to spark [[Guilting]].

	[[Guilting]] can also occur in games with [[Turn Taking]] or which are [[Turn-Based Games]], here due to players try to make other players suffering from [[Analysis Paralysis]] quickly decide what to do next.		[[Guilting]] can also occur in games with [[Turn Taking]] or which are [[Turn-Based Games]], here due to players try to make other players suffering from [[Analysis Paralysis]] quickly decide what to do next.
Line 43:		Line 43:
	[[Guilds]],		[[Guilds]],
	[[Loyalty]],		[[Loyalty]],
			[[Mutual FUBAR Enjoyment]],
	[[Social Dilemmas]],		[[Social Dilemmas]],
	[[Social Organizations]],		[[Social Organizations]],

Staffan Björk at 14:03, 17 July 2014

2014-07-17T14:03:33Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 14:03, 17 July 2014
Line 24:		Line 24:
	== Consequences ==		== Consequences ==
	Since feeling guilt is rarely a pleasurable experience, being on the receiving end of [[Guilting]], or even seeing that this may occur, can lead to [[Tension]].		Since feeling guilt is rarely a pleasurable experience, being on the receiving end of [[Guilting]], or even seeing that this may occur, can lead to [[Tension]].

			The possibility of [[Guilting]] opens up for [[Social Roles]] both on the sending and receiving end of the [[Guilting]].

	== Relations ==		== Relations ==
	=== Can Instantiate ===		=== Can Instantiate ===
			[[Social Roles]],
	[[Tension]]		[[Tension]]

Staffan Björk at 15:12, 7 January 2013

2013-01-07T15:12:13Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 15:12, 7 January 2013
Line 1:		Line 1:
			[[Category:Subjective Patterns]]
	[[Category:Patterns]]		[[Category:Patterns]]
	[[Category:Negative Patterns]]		[[Category:Negative Patterns]]

Staffan Björk at 08:34, 9 October 2012

2012-10-09T08:34:44Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 08:34, 9 October 2012
Line 18:		Line 18:

	[[Guilting]] can also occur in games with [[Turn Taking]] or which are [[Turn-Based Games]], here due to players try to make other players suffering from [[Analysis Paralysis]] quickly decide what to do next.		[[Guilting]] can also occur in games with [[Turn Taking]] or which are [[Turn-Based Games]], here due to players try to make other players suffering from [[Analysis Paralysis]] quickly decide what to do next.

			While [[Guilting]] can occur in any game with [[Unmediated Social Interaction]], the presence of [[Chat Channels]] in games with [[Mediated Gameplay]] can give rise to the pattern as well.

	== Consequences ==		== Consequences ==
Line 32:		Line 34:
	[[Altruistic Actions]],		[[Altruistic Actions]],
	[[Asynchronous Collaborative Actions]],		[[Asynchronous Collaborative Actions]],
			[[Chat Channels]],
	[[Delayed Reciprocity]],		[[Delayed Reciprocity]],
	[[Free Gift Inventories]],		[[Free Gift Inventories]],
Line 39:		Line 42:
	[[Social Organizations]],		[[Social Organizations]],
	[[Symbiotic Player Relations]],		[[Symbiotic Player Relations]],
	[[Teams]]		[[Teams]],
			[[Unmediated Social Interaction]]

	[[Analysis Paralysis]] together with [[Turn Taking]] or [[Turn-Based Games]]		[[Analysis Paralysis]] together with [[Turn Taking]] or [[Turn-Based Games]]

Staffan Björk at 07:39, 8 October 2012

2012-10-08T07:39:23Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 07:39, 8 October 2012
Line 15:		Line 15:

	== Using the pattern ==		== Using the pattern ==
	[[Guilting]] consists of two parts. The first part is that players have other players they feel a connection with. This can be formalized [[Social Organizations]] such as [[Teams]] or [[Guilds]], but any group that they feel [[Loyalty]] to can suffice as can other players with which they have [[Symbiotic Player Relations]]. The second part of [[Guilting]] is to make players feel that they should perform some form of action to other players. This is quite often set up by [[Delayed Reciprocity]], for example through [[Altruistic Actions]] such as [[Free Gift Inventories]], but any type of [[Social Dilemmas]] can work as well. Another option to create [[Guilting]] is to put one or more players in a state of [[Helplessness]] and then let them ask for help through [[Communication Channels]] or [[Unmediated Social Interaction]].		[[Guilting]] consists of two parts. The first part is that players have other players they feel a connection with. This can be formalized [[Social Organizations]] such as [[Teams]] or [[Guilds]], but any group that they feel [[Loyalty]] to can suffice as can other players with which they have [[Symbiotic Player Relations]]. The second part of [[Guilting]] is to make players feel that they should perform some form of action to other players. This is quite often set up by [[Delayed Reciprocity]], for example through [[Altruistic Actions]] such as [[Free Gift Inventories]], but any type of [[Social Dilemmas]] can work as well. [[Asynchronous Collaborative Actions]] shows how [[Social Dilemmas]] can be used for this purpose without the players needing to interact directly with each other, or even know much about each other. Another option to create [[Guilting]] is to put one or more players in a state of [[Helplessness]] and then let them ask for help through [[Communication Channels]] or [[Unmediated Social Interaction]].

	[[Guilting]] can also occur in games with [[Turn Taking]] or which are [[Turn-Based Games]], here due to players try to make other players suffering from [[Analysis Paralysis]] quickly decide what to do next.		[[Guilting]] can also occur in games with [[Turn Taking]] or which are [[Turn-Based Games]], here due to players try to make other players suffering from [[Analysis Paralysis]] quickly decide what to do next.
Line 31:		Line 31:
	=== Can Be Instantiated By ===		=== Can Be Instantiated By ===
	[[Altruistic Actions]],		[[Altruistic Actions]],
			[[Asynchronous Collaborative Actions]],
	[[Delayed Reciprocity]],		[[Delayed Reciprocity]],
	[[Free Gift Inventories]],		[[Free Gift Inventories]],

Staffan Björk at 10:26, 20 January 2012

2012-01-20T10:26:39Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 10:26, 20 January 2012
Line 15:		Line 15:

	== Using the pattern ==		== Using the pattern ==
	[[Guilting]] consists of two parts. The first part is that players have other players they feel a connection with. This can be formalized [[Social Organizations]] such as [[Teams]] or [[Guilds]], but any group that they feel [[Loyalty]] to can suffice. The second part of [[Guilting]] is to make players feel that they should perform some form of action to other players. This is quite often set up by [[Delayed Reciprocity]], for example through [[Altruistic Actions]] such as [[Free Gift Inventories]], but any type of [[Social Dilemmas]] can work as well. Another option to create [[Guilting]] is to put one or more players in a state of [[Helplessness]] and then let them ask for help through [[Communication Channels]] or [[Unmediated Social Interaction]].		[[Guilting]] consists of two parts. The first part is that players have other players they feel a connection with. This can be formalized [[Social Organizations]] such as [[Teams]] or [[Guilds]], but any group that they feel [[Loyalty]] to can suffice as can other players with which they have [[Symbiotic Player Relations]]. The second part of [[Guilting]] is to make players feel that they should perform some form of action to other players. This is quite often set up by [[Delayed Reciprocity]], for example through [[Altruistic Actions]] such as [[Free Gift Inventories]], but any type of [[Social Dilemmas]] can work as well. Another option to create [[Guilting]] is to put one or more players in a state of [[Helplessness]] and then let them ask for help through [[Communication Channels]] or [[Unmediated Social Interaction]].

	[[Guilting]] can also occur in games with [[Turn Taking]] or which are [[Turn-Based Games]], here due to players try to make other players suffering from [[Analysis Paralysis]] quickly decide what to do next.		[[Guilting]] can also occur in games with [[Turn Taking]] or which are [[Turn-Based Games]], here due to players try to make other players suffering from [[Analysis Paralysis]] quickly decide what to do next.
Line 37:		Line 37:
	[[Social Dilemmas]],		[[Social Dilemmas]],
	[[Social Organizations]],		[[Social Organizations]],
			[[Symbiotic Player Relations]],
	[[Teams]]		[[Teams]]

Staffan Björk at 17:26, 3 June 2011

2011-06-03T17:26:40Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 17:26, 3 June 2011
Line 17:		Line 17:
	[[Guilting]] consists of two parts. The first part is that players have other players they feel a connection with. This can be formalized [[Social Organizations]] such as [[Teams]] or [[Guilds]], but any group that they feel [[Loyalty]] to can suffice. The second part of [[Guilting]] is to make players feel that they should perform some form of action to other players. This is quite often set up by [[Delayed Reciprocity]], for example through [[Altruistic Actions]] such as [[Free Gift Inventories]], but any type of [[Social Dilemmas]] can work as well. Another option to create [[Guilting]] is to put one or more players in a state of [[Helplessness]] and then let them ask for help through [[Communication Channels]] or [[Unmediated Social Interaction]].		[[Guilting]] consists of two parts. The first part is that players have other players they feel a connection with. This can be formalized [[Social Organizations]] such as [[Teams]] or [[Guilds]], but any group that they feel [[Loyalty]] to can suffice. The second part of [[Guilting]] is to make players feel that they should perform some form of action to other players. This is quite often set up by [[Delayed Reciprocity]], for example through [[Altruistic Actions]] such as [[Free Gift Inventories]], but any type of [[Social Dilemmas]] can work as well. Another option to create [[Guilting]] is to put one or more players in a state of [[Helplessness]] and then let them ask for help through [[Communication Channels]] or [[Unmediated Social Interaction]].

	[[Guilting]] can also occur in games with [[Turn Taking]], ~~where~~ players try to make players suffering from [[Analysis Paralysis]] to quickly decide what to do next.		[[Guilting]] can also occur in games with [[Turn Taking]] or which are [[Turn-Based Games]], here due to players try to make other players suffering from [[Analysis Paralysis]] quickly decide what to do next.

	== Consequences ==		== Consequences ==
Line 39:		Line 39:
	[[Teams]]		[[Teams]]

	[[Analysis Paralysis]] together with [[Turn Taking]]		[[Analysis Paralysis]] together with [[Turn Taking]] or [[Turn-Based Games]]

	[[Helplessness]] together with [[Communication Channels]] or [[Unmediated Social Interaction]]		[[Helplessness]] together with [[Communication Channels]] or [[Unmediated Social Interaction]]

Staffan Björk at 20:14, 15 March 2011

2011-03-15T20:14:48Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 20:14, 15 March 2011
Line 15:		Line 15:

	== Using the pattern ==		== Using the pattern ==
	[[Guilting]] consists of two parts. The first part is that players have other players they feel a connection with. This can be formalized [[Social Organizations]] such as [[Guilds]], but any group that they feel [[Loyalty]] to can suffice. The second part of [[Guilting]] is to make players feel that they should perform some form of action to other players. This is quite often set up by [[Delayed Reciprocity]], for example through [[Altruistic Actions]] such as [[Free Gift Inventories]], but any type of [[Social Dilemmas]] can work as well.		[[Guilting]] consists of two parts. The first part is that players have other players they feel a connection with. This can be formalized [[Social Organizations]] such as [[Teams]] or [[Guilds]], but any group that they feel [[Loyalty]] to can suffice. The second part of [[Guilting]] is to make players feel that they should perform some form of action to other players. This is quite often set up by [[Delayed Reciprocity]], for example through [[Altruistic Actions]] such as [[Free Gift Inventories]], but any type of [[Social Dilemmas]] can work as well. Another option to create [[Guilting]] is to put one or more players in a state of [[Helplessness]] and then let them ask for help through [[Communication Channels]] or [[Unmediated Social Interaction]].

	[[Guilting]] can also occur in games with [[Turn Taking]], where players try to make players suffering from [[Analysis Paralysis]] to quickly decide what to do next.		[[Guilting]] can also occur in games with [[Turn Taking]], where players try to make players suffering from [[Analysis Paralysis]] to quickly decide what to do next.
Line 36:		Line 36:
	[[Loyalty]],		[[Loyalty]],
	[[Social Dilemmas]],		[[Social Dilemmas]],
	[[Social Organizations]]		[[Social Organizations]],
			[[Teams]]

	[[Analysis Paralysis]] together with [[Turn Taking]]		[[Analysis Paralysis]] together with [[Turn Taking]]

			[[Helplessness]] together with [[Communication Channels]] or [[Unmediated Social Interaction]]

	=== Can Be Modulated By ===		=== Can Be Modulated By ===